New Palestine Homes under $400,000

New Palestine Homes under $400,000

Welcome to New Palestine, Indiana – a charming town nestled in the heart of Hancock County, where small-town charm meets modern conveniences. Just a short drive from the bustling city of Indianapolis, New Palestine offers a serene retreat with easy access to urban amenities, making it an ideal place for families, professionals, and retirees alike.

As you stroll through the picturesque streets of New Palestine, you'll find a warm community spirit reflected in its friendly residents and local events. The town boasts beautiful parks, excellent schools, and a variety of recreational opportunities, ensuring that there’s something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you’re looking to explore the scenic trails, engage in community activities, or simply relax in a welcoming atmosphere, New Palestine has it all.

For those in search of a new home, New Palestine presents an incredible opportunity with a range of beautiful properties available for under $400,000. This budget-friendly market allows you to find spacious single-family homes, charming bungalows, and modern townhouses without breaking the bank. Many of these homes feature updated amenities, large backyards, and are conveniently located near schools and parks, making them perfect for families looking to settle down.

With its rich history, vibrant community, and affordable housing options, New Palestine is more than just a place to live; it’s a place to thrive. Come discover your dream home in this delightful Indiana town, where every day feels like a warm welcome home.

Newest New Palestine Homes under $400,000

7721 W 200 Road S, New Palestine
$399,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Enjoy room to spread out in a country setting without being far from everyday conveniences! This 3-bedroom, 2-bath home sits on 1.3 acres with woods along the back. The inviting family room features brand-new LVP flooring and a cozy gas-log fireplace, while the kitchen offers an island with room for seating. Step outside to the spacious new TimberTech Advanced PVC deck with a pergola-perfect for entertaining or simply relaxing. A pole barn provides space for tinkering, hobbies, or projects, and an invisible fence adds convenience for your furry friends. The roof, furnace, and AC are approximately five years old, and the water heater is just one year old. Space, comfort, and outdoor enjoyment await!

7721 W 200 Road S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indy Metro NE.

6205 W 300 S Road S, New Palestine
$297,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Some homes just feel right the moment you arrive. Nestled in the charming community of New Palestine, just a short drive from Indianapolis, this sweet two-bedroom charmer sits on a generous .59-acre lot and delivers that rare combination, the unhurried feeling of small town living with easy access to everything the city offers. The newly improved 600 South corridor opens up a lovely path to the public schools and the beloved Pennsy Trail - a wonderful bonus for walkers, cyclists, and families alike. You'll love this home with its loads of updates! The kitchen is a delight, light and airy, appointed with white cabinetry, updated countertops, a wall oven, cooktop, and direct access to the deck. The dining room offers full windows overlooking the backyard with space for a desk or a cherished plant collection, a room that functions well. A warm and inviting family room offers easy access to the backyard, making indoor and outdoor living feel effortlessly connected. The primary bedroom leads to a surprisingly beautiful updated bath featuring a full tiled shower, new counter & sink, and walk-in closet. A genuine upgrade you might not expect at this price point. A two-year-old deck with wrought iron-style railings invites you to linger. And then there is the barn, a proper little red barn with white cross doors, lovingly rebuilt and expanded with a handsome covered lean-to supported by timbers that give it real presence and shelter. Honestly, it might be your most favorite thing about the property! The unfinished basement offers excellent storage and laundry hookups, with additional stackable connections available in the main level hall closet. You will not believe all the updates; too numerous to list here. Lovingly maintained and quietly waiting, with a full updates sheet available. Some houses are just houses. This one feels like home.

6205 W 300 S Road S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

4860 W Safford Drive, New Palestine
$398,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Some homes simply give you more space. This one gives you more ways to live. With 5 bedrooms, 3.5 baths and more than 3,100 sq ft, this New Palestine home was made for life's changing seasons whether that means a growing household, welcoming family under one roof, working from home or simply having room for everyone to feel at home. A main-level bedroom and full bath offer comfortable space for guests or extended family, while the flexible front room can become the office, playroom or dining room that fits your life. The kitchen and great room are where life naturally comes together. The large island becomes the place for morning coffee, quick breakfasts, homework and conversations while dinner is being made. Quartz countertops, updated appliances, tile backsplash, generous pantry storage, crown molding, fresh paint and thoughtful updates make the home feel both welcoming and ready to enjoy. Step outside and you may find your favorite place. Thoughtful landscaping and a spacious patio create a backyard oasis for quiet mornings, summer dinners and evenings spent with family and friends. With no immediate neighbor behind or beside the home and open common space beyond, there's a wonderful sense of openness that's hard to appreciate until you see it. Upstairs, everyone has room to spread out with a spacious loft, 4 generously sized bedrooms, large closets and the convenience of an upstairs laundry room. The primary suite offers a comfortable place to unwind, complete with double vanities and a walk-in closet with custom shelving. Copperstone adds even more to everyday life with sidewalks, a community pool and playground. It's a home with room to gather, room to grow and room for whatever comes next.

4860 W Safford Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of F.C. Tucker Company.

6349 W Buckskin Court, New Palestine
$315,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Room to spread out, settle in, and enjoy more space inside and out at 6349 W Buckskin Ct in New Palestine. Situated on just over half an acre, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch offers 1,822 square feet of comfortable single-level living with a layout built for everyday functionality. Inside, the home offers generous living spaces with plenty of flexibility for relaxing, gathering, working from home, or creating a space that fits your lifestyle. Three bedrooms provide versatility for sleeping, guests, hobbies, or a dedicated home office, while two full bathrooms keep the floor plan practical and convenient. Outside is where the possibilities really expand. The more than half-acre lot provides plenty of room for outdoor entertaining, gardening, recreation, or simply enjoying a backyard with breathing room. Whether your vision includes evenings around a fire pit, weekend cookouts, or creating your own outdoor retreat, there's space to make it happen. With its ranch-style layout, spacious lot, and New Palestine location, 6349 W Buckskin Ct offers the combination of indoor comfort and outdoor space that's becoming increasingly difficult to find.

6349 W Buckskin Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine
$282,500
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Set on 0.62 acres in New Palestine, this well-maintained brick ranch offers the space, privacy, and single-level living buyers are looking for. With 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, and 1,577 square feet, the home features a spacious living room anchored by a wood-burning fireplace, an eat-in kitchen with breakfast bar, and a welcoming foyer. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and private bath with a separate tub and shower, while two additional bedrooms provide flexibility for family, guests, or a home office. Outside, enjoy a large fully fenced backyard with plenty of room to entertain, garden, play, or simply relax beneath the mature trees. A mini barn adds convenient extra storage, and the attached finished 2-car garage provides even more functionality. With no HOA and more than half an acre, there is room to spread out without giving up convenient access to New Palestine and the Southern Hancock County school system. Whether you're drawn to the classic brick exterior, generous yard, cozy fireplace, or easy ranch-style floor plan, this property offers a comfortable place to call home with space both inside and out.

5311 W 300 S, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Mark Dietel Realty, LLC.

2448 S Sunrise Drive, New Palestine
$380,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Some homes impress with finishes. Others win you over with the things that are much harder to find-and nearly impossible to recreate. Set on 1.5 peaceful acres at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac with no HOA, this stone home offers the rare combination of a picturesque neighborhood setting, exceptional privacy, & the space and freedom of country living. Surrounded by custom-built stone & brick homes, the property feels tucked away without feeling isolated. Inside, the thoughtful one-level floor plan offers 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, 1/2 bath, a dedicated office, dining room, & an open kitchen flowing into the vaulted Great Room, where a beautiful stone fireplace creates a natural focal point. But the room that may quickly become your favorite is the expansive three-season room. Surrounded by windows on three sides, it overlooks the private backyard & offers a front-row seat to every season-a space for morning coffee, quiet afternoons, social gatherings, and enjoying the view. Step outside and the setting becomes even more special. With Breier Creek meandering along the back edge of the property, the backyard feels peaceful and private with room to enjoy the outdoors. A rear paver patio provides the perfect spot for grilling & gathering, while the welcoming front porch w/paver patio overlooking the shady front yard offer another quiet place to relax. This home has been loved and maintained by the same family for 35 years, with important improvements already made to the roof, mechanicals, well and septic. Ready for the next owner to add their own aesthetic touches, the home offers the qualities that matter most: solid construction, an incredibly functional floor plan, generous spaces, one-level living & a beautiful piece of land. SD states AC 13 years but the serial number shows 2024. Water Heater 2016, Furnace new heat pump 2024 & annually serviced. Asphalt Driveway recently sealed, Vinyl Windows 2012, Sealed Stone Exterior 2024, Fireplace is "AS IS".

2448 S Sunrise Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Keller Williams Indpls Metro N.

4732 S Grassy Court, New Palestine
$375,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths
Space to enjoy inside and out at 4732 S Grassy Ct in New Palestine. Situated on approximately .60 acres, this 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch offers 1,716 square feet of comfortable single-level living with a layout designed for everyday functionality and easy entertaining. Inside, you'll find inviting living spaces with plenty of room to gather, unwind, and make the home your own. The three-bedroom layout provides flexibility beyond traditional sleeping spaces, with options for a home office, guest room, hobby space, or whatever best fits your needs. Two full bathrooms plus an additional half bath add everyday convenience. The garage is heated and has great workshop space. Outside, the generous lot gives this property another dimension entirely. With more than half an acre, there's room to enjoy the outdoors, entertain, garden, play, or simply appreciate having additional space around you. An attached garage adds parking and storage, while the ranch-style floor plan keeps everyday living comfortably on one level. For buyers searching for a ranch home in New Palestine with a large lot, flexible living space, and room to enjoy both indoors and out, 4732 S Grassy Ct deserves a closer look.

4732 S Grassy Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

4602 W Dane Court, New Palestine
$389,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome home to this beautifully maintained 3-bedroom, 2-full-bath ranch with a spacious loft, offering 2,383 square feet of comfortable and versatile living space. Situated on a large corner lot, this property is a gardener's dream. The thoughtfully designed outdoor space features professionally installed raised stone garden beds and spruce trees, fruit trees, beautiful landscaping, and a privacy fence. A concrete patio provides the perfect space for outdoor furniture and relaxing or entertaining, while the sunroom overlooks the expansive backyard and offers a peaceful spot to enjoy your morning coffee or unwind while taking in the beautifully landscaped surroundings. Inside, the inviting main living area features vaulted ceilings and new flooring. The stylish and functional kitchen offers quartz countertops, modern white cabinetry, a beautiful backsplash, and newer stainless steel appliances-perfect for everyday living and entertaining. The primary suite includes a walk-in closet and a generously sized en-suite bath with a separate garden tub and shower. Upstairs, the versatile loft provides additional space for a home office, hobby area, playroom, workout space, or second living area. Inside and out, this home has been thoughtfully updated, beautifully maintained, and designed to offer plenty of space to relax, entertain, garden, and enjoy the outdoors.

4602 W Dane Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of The Real Estate Group LLC.

4935 W Harrisburg Court, New Palestine
$330,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Welcome home to this beautifully maintained, all brick 2 bedrrom, 2 bathroom, one-owner condo in a desirable New Palestine location! Immaculately cared for and filled with natural light, this inviting home features an open-concept floor plan with soaring cathedral ceilings, hardwood floors, and an abundance of windows that create a bright and welcoming atmosphere. The spacious kitchen is designed for both everyday living and entertaining, featuring a large center island, granite countertops, stainless steel appliances, and plenty of cabinet and counter space. The generously sized primary suite offers a tray ceiling with ceiling fan and a private bath complete with double sinks a large walk-in shower and walk in closet. The convenient laundry room includes a utility sink for added functionality. Thoughtfully designed with accessibility in mind, the home features 36-inch interior doors, providing additional ease of access if needed. Outside, enjoy a private rear patio surrounded by small trees that provide a pleasant sense of privacy. Best of all, the HOA handles the lawn care and exterior maintenance, including the roof, allowing you to enjoy a low-maintenance lifestyle and spend more time enjoying your home. With its desirable location, exceptional condition, thoughtful features, and easy-care lifestyle, this condo is a must-see!

4935 W Harrisburg Court, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ever Real Estate, LLC.

2932 High Acres East Street, New Palestine
$269,500
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Built in 1981, this inviting 1131 square foot residence offers a comfortable and practical design. This home provides two comfortable bedrooms, offering flexible living arrangements. A full bathroom serves the primary needs of the household, complemented by an additional half bathroom for convenience. The 21780 square foot lot provides generous outdoor space for various activities and potential landscaping endeavors. To truly appreciate the potential of this delightful property, schedule a private viewing today.

2932 High Acres East Street, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Going Property Group, LLC.

4781 W Safford Drive, New Palestine
$399,900
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths
Enjoy expansive, unobstructed views of the community pond, fountain, and open green space right from your fully fenced backyard at 4781 W Safford Drive. This 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath home features more than 3,100 square feet of living space designed for daily function. The main floor offers a dedicated home office behind French doors, plus a rare main level bedroom with an private full bathroom. In the kitchen, a large center island serves as the hub, opening directly to the dining and main living spaces. Storage is a major focus here, from the walk-in kitchen pantry to the built-in drop zone near the garage for shoes and bags. Upstairs, a massive central loft provides a second living room, game space, or home gym. The primary suite includes a private bathroom with double vanities, a tiled shower, and a large walk-in closet. You will find extra walk-in closets throughout the home for storage, along with an upstairs laundry room situated near the bedrooms. Located in the Copperstone neighborhood of New Palestine, you get access to the community pool and playground, plus a quick commute to local schools, parks, and shopping. An additional upgrade is a built-in reverse osmosis system. TVs with wall mounts, deep freezer in garage, and the playset stay!

4781 W Safford Drive, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway Home.

4665 Black Willow Way, New Palestine
$372,995
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths
Photos are of the same floor plan; finishes and features may vary. Projected for completion in early November 2026, this thoughtfully designed Eisenhower floor plan in Willow Ridge offers ranch-style living, modern comfort, functional design, and the peace of mind of new construction with a builder warranty. The main level features a bright, open-concept layout where the kitchen, nook, and great room flow seamlessly together, creating an inviting space for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen serves as the heart of the open-concept living area, offering a center island, ample cabinetry, and seamless connection to both the nook and great room. The private primary suite is tucked away for added comfort and includes an en-suite bath, walk-in closet, and easy access to the laundry room. Two additional bedrooms and a full bath provide flexible space for family, guests, a home office, or hobbies. Additional highlights include a spacious 3-car garage, covered front entry, and convenient main-level living throughout. Located in Willow Ridge, residents enjoy easy access to Interstate 465, U.S. 52, and major roadways for a quick commute to Indianapolis. Nearby shopping and dining destinations include New Towne Square and New Palestine Plaza, while outdoor recreation opportunities can be found at Sugar Creek Township Park and local walking trails. Within the community, a charming playground and serene pond views enhance the neighborhood setting. As a new construction home, enjoy turnkey living with contemporary design, efficiency, and the added peace of mind of builder warranty coverage. Learn more today.

4665 Black Willow Way, New Palestine

Listing courtesy of Ridgeline Realty, LLC.

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative